In 2005 Christopher Booker wrote a book called The Seven Basic Plots: Why We Tell Stories. The premise of the book is that all stories, from Shakespeare to Noddy, involve one of these plots, just written in different ways.
For example, both Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone by J.K Rowling and 1984 by George Orwell are about Overcoming a Monster. In the first it’s a literal monster, and in the second the monster is the oppressive government, but both stories deal with an attempt to overcome at any rate. Overcoming the monster is, of course, one of his seven. The other 6 are:
Quest
Voyage and return
Comedy
Tragedy
Rebirth
Rags to riches
I am, I have to admit, slightly confused in writing this because I always though that bildungsroman was in that list, but apparently not!
Anyway, the theory of this book is that every story can be categorised under one of these seven headings, and no one has come up with an original idea in centuries.
But I am struggling to come up with a book that doesn’t fall under one of those seven headings! Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is both a Rags to Riches and a Quest. Of Mice and Men is a Tragedy. The Lord of the Rings is a Quest, Overcoming the Monster and Voyage and Return. Anna Karenina could probably fit all seven depending on how you look at it!
What do you think? Is Booker right or are his basic plots are so broad that they cover everything just by being non-specific?
Also, are we just rehashing the same ideas over and over again, or are there still original stories that haven’t been written yet?